Skip to main content.

DSM 5 – Misdiagnosing or Mislabeling of Medical Diseases

DSM 5 – Misdiagnosing or Mislabeling of Medical Diseases

Picture of Kate  Benson

The psychiatric world is close to receiving an updated version of their “Bible.” Officially known as the DSM 5 this tome, published by the Association of Psychiatrists,  under goes revision every couple of decades often accompanied by contentious issues and rancor from psychiatrists, psychologists and patient groups as ideology changes. Most diagnoses do not have an objective means of diagnosis and depend on subjective characteristics defined by committee. 

One of the biggest critics of the current DSM 5 is psychiatrist Dr. Allen Frances who chaired a previous edition.  Prominent in the news has been the changing of the definition of autism and the inclusion of bereaved people under depression, but there are other issues that have received less time in the spotlight.  

But, Frances also highlights the issue of mislabeling medical illness as a mental disorder. Less well known perhaps is a quiet backwater group focusing on the intersection between disease and psychosocial issues. Once labeled psychosomatic illnesses, the group now focuses on whether patients are too worried about being ill and the criteria are rather broad according to critics.  Frances, in a recent column, argues that there are two issues: encouraging a quick jump to the erroneous conclusion that someone's physical symptoms are 'all in the head' and mislabeling as mental disorders what are really just the normal emotional reactions that people understandably have in response to a medical illness.

Frances then quotes a source as saying, “One in six cancer and coronary disease patients met the criteria for DSM-5 'Somatic Symptom Disorder.' Do we really want to burden and stigmatize seriously ill people with an additional diagnosis of mental illness, just because they are worried about being sick and are vigilant about their symptoms?

Another issue may be whether medical patients labeled with psychiatric diagnoses get the same quality and type of care offered to patients without such a label. A recent Australian study notes psychiatric patients with a cancer diagnosis were less likely to receive specialized cancer treatments compared with the general population. The authors concluded "These results could suggest inequitable access to appropriate care, especially given that reduced access to treatment persisted after controlling for the presence of metastases." 

Image by Stephen Cummings via Flickr

Comments

Picture of

The DSM allows abusive and neglectful caregivers to label children in their care with 'Behviour Disorders'. Diagnosis by Child Behaviour Checklist where the child is diagnosed on the basis of the unsubstantiated word of a potential abuser is violation of a child's rights. Similarly diagnosing as resistance, opposition, etc., i.e. the cries for help and or coping mechanisms used by the abused in attempt to control the uncontrollable traumatising environment in which they live - requiring them to be hyper-vigilant. Under no circumstances should any child be diagnosed by reification. As it is in the case of children with physical injuries the possibility of potential physical abuse is checked. Strict controls must be identified and adhered to before any lethal DSM Diagnosis is made

Leave A Comment

Announcements

COVID-19 has made every journalist a health reporter, whether their usual beat is crime, education or county government.  Our 2021 California Fellowship will make anyone who attends a better health reporter -- and give you a reporting grant of $2,000-$10,000 and five months of mentoring while you work on an ambitious project. Deadline to apply: March 1.

In our next webinar, we’ll analyze Biden’s COVID-19 strategy in the first 100 days — and the huge obstacles the new federal effort must confront. We’ll also look at how Biden plans to address the economic devastation wrought by the pandemic, with a focus on women and vulnerable families. Sign-up here!

CONNECT WITH THE COMMUNITY

Follow Us

Facebook


Twitter

CHJ Icon
ReportingHealth