Legislative Proposals to Protect the Immigrant Community in California

California's immigrant community is increasingly avoiding medical care due to fear of immigration enforcement. As previously reported, migrants like Alicia Romo are canceling appointments out of concern that hospital visits could lead to detention. This growing healthcare access crisis has prompted hospitals and clinics statewide to report significant decreases in patients seeking medical attention, as immigrants weigh their health needs against the risk of encountering immigration agents.

In response, the Latino Legislative Caucus has proposed protective legislation, including two key bills focused on healthcare settings. Senator Jesse Arreguín's SB 81 would designate hospitals and clinics as safe spaces by restricting ICE access to non-public areas without judicial warrants and preventing immigration authorities from accessing patients' immigration status. Meanwhile, Assemblymember Jose Luis Solache's AB 421 would create one-mile protection zones around hospitals, churches, and daycares, prohibiting state and local authorities from cooperating with immigration agencies within these areas.

Image

While both measures are designed to take immediate effect if signed into law, their real-world implementation and impact remain uncertain. Political Science Professor Andrés Quintero notes that although federal law takes precedence, California's police powers provide constitutional grounds for state-level immigrant protections. The ultimate challenge will be rebuilding trust within immigrant communities and ensuring that these legal safeguards translate into actual healthcare access for all residents, regardless of immigration status.

This project was supported by the USC Annenberg Center for Health Journalism, and is part of “Healing California”, a yearlong reporting Ethnic Media Collaborative venture with print, online and broadcast outlets across California.